Taiwan's Social Work Profession Development: Professionalism vs. National Professionalism
The beginning of this chapter claims that Taiwan's social work profession was brought about merely by means of strategies rather than by the accomplishment of skills or the maturity of the social work environment. However, through the process of compiling the developmental history of Taiwan's social work profession it can be seen that government plays an indispensible role in the profession. Throughout history, government was sometimes the leader that protected benefits, sometimes the object to fight against, and sometimes an ally. On the one hand, the social work profession serves as a key element during the forming of a nation (e.g., the
Japanese colonial period and the Kuomintang government period); on the other, the establishment of the profession also requires acts such as the incorporation of social workers and the legislation from the government.
Since 'certification' is employed in Taiwan within the social work system, its effect of regulation inevitably divides those who are competent from those who are not. On the basis of law, the competent ones provide specialized services based on their specialized knowledge and skills; although the certification system proposed by the government is supposed to protect professional service personnel and consumers, in fact it allows professional groups to maintain their economic power and elitism in education and society. Thus, the certification system has become a regulatory captive or is controlled by professional organizations (Wilson, 1984). However, the government is, in law, the power that should control these organizations.
Following the above arguments, we believe that to discuss the development of social work as a profession in Taiwan, it is necessary to look into its relationship with government. In Taiwan, ever since the application of national examinations, the development of social work as a profession in Taiwan has always wandered between professionalism and national professionalism. This is a unique phenomenon: Looking at the development of Taiwan's social work profession from the perspective of both the government and the profession, it can be seen that in the early stages, collective power of an alliance urged for the birth of the Social Worker Act, yet professional autonomy was later set back and weakened by the government intervention. Apparently the professional organizations resumed control during the period of amendments when means such as negotiation and public hearings were applied to make voices in the community heard. Nevertheless, the outcome emerged, hinting at the unbalanced situation whereby academics eventually became the representatives of the profession and the government, with social workers being clients.
The development of social work as a profession in Taiwan appeared to be a process wherein a single service provider could manage to form and control the 'market' of 'profession'. When the buyer was the government or vested interest groups, 'profession' was forced to face the buyer-dominated market and transformed into national professionalism. This chapter shows the phenomenon and emphasizes the connection between professionalization and national professionalism, yet it is not possible to point out which party is more superior. What is the ultimate outcome of the two parties' inter-influence? The answer is left to time to reveal.
Caplow, T. (1954), The Sociology of Work. Minneapolis: University of Minneapolis
Carr-Saunders, A.M. and Wilson, P.A. (1962), The Emergence of Professions, in Man, Work and Society, edited by S. Nosow and W.H. Form. New York: Basic Books. Chang, S.C. (1978), The Idea of Social Work Professionalization in Taiwan,
China Forum, Vol. 6, No. 10, pp. 8–11 (in Chinese).
Chang, Y.H. (1991), Review and Prospect of the Social Work Profession System in Taiwan, Social Work Journal, Vol. 1, pp. 1–14 (in Chinese).
Chen, C.C. et al. (2005), Social Workers Working Conditions Survey, Community Development Journal Quarterly, Vol. 109, pp. 475–86 (in Chinese).
Chen, W.T. (2003), Between Name and Reality: Reflect Professional Development Education after Social Worker National Examination, Paper presented at the Role of Social Workers and Social Work Education Seminar, Taichung: Tunghai University (in Chinese).
Cheng, L.C. (2008), The Dialogue between Social Work Professionalism and Social Work License, National Elite Quarterly, Vol. 4, No. 4, pp. 127–40.
Chiang, L.Y. (2002), Japanese Social Work Education, Training and Social Welfare Worker, Community Development Journal Quarterly, Vol. 99, pp. 156–65 (in Chinese).
Chien, C.A. and Tao, F.Y. (1993), Taiwan Social Work Professional Development, paper presented at the Conference of Social Work Profession System, Taipei, Taiwan (in Chinese).
Chou, Y.C. (2002), The Crisis and Turning Point of the Development of Taiwan's Social Work Profession: Reflections on Social Work Education and Practice, Community Development Quarterly, Vol. 99, pp. 90–125 (in Chinese).
Chuang, H.M. (2004), Taiwan's Social Welfare and Social Works during the Japanese Colonial Period, Soochow Journal of Social Work, Vol. 10, pp. 1–33.
Collins, R. (1979), The Credential Society: An Historical Sociological of Education
and Stratification. Academic Press: New York.
Fang, L. and Cheng, L.C. (1999), The Inquiry of Social Work Professional Autonomy―For Example in the Event of Taipei Licensed Prostitutes, Community Development Journal Quarterly, Vol. 86, pp. 208–15.
Fang, Y. (2004), The Action and Narration of “Qing-Shui-Gou”: My Community Work Practice and Criticism of Professional Social Work. Unpublished Master's thesis from the Department of Social Work, Soochow University, Taipei.
Fang, Y.L. (1999), The Government's Social Work Dilemma in the Event of Taipei Licensed Prostitutes: A Reflection of Action Research, thesis, Department of Social Work, National Taiwan University, Taiwan (in Chinese).
Flexner, A. (1915), Is Social Work a Profession? Research on Social Practice, Vol.
11, No. 2, pp. 152–65.
Freidson, E. (1970), The Profession of Medicine. University of Chicago Press:
Freidson, E. (1994), Professionalism Reborn: Theory, Prophecy and Policy, Polity
Press: Cambridge, UK.
Ho, T.Y. (2004), A Study on Career Transfer of Social Worker: An Example of Qualified Social Worker in Local Government, thesis, Department of Social Policy and Social Work, National Chi Nan University, Puli, Taiwan.
Hsa, J.C. and Lin, W.I. (1984), Contemporary Social Work. Wu Nan: Taipei. Hsiao H.J. (2005), Reflections on Taiwan's Social Work Certification System, Based on the Comparisons of Taiwan and the USA's Social Work Certification System, thesis, Department of Social Work, National Taiwan University, Taipei (in Chinese).
Hsiao, H.B. (2006), Formation of Consensus or Setback for Imagination? In Inspection of Professional Sociology: The Social Work Issue in Society, thesis, Dept. of Sociology, Ching Hua University: Hsinchu, Taiwan.
Hsu, C.Y. (2004). Social Work Education in Taiwan: Testing Development of Degree Theses, 1990–2003, thesis, Department of Social Policy and Social Work, National Chi Nan University, Puli, Taiwan.
Huang et al. (2002), Overall Survey of the Social Welfare System. The Control Yuan: Taipei (in Chinese).
Huang, Y.H. (1999), New Managerialism, Community Care and Social Work, Community Development Journal Quarterly, Vol. 85, pp. 200–213 (in Chinese). Huang, Y.S. (2006), Construction of Long-Term Care Quality Management System, Community-Based Long Term Care Quarterly, Vol. 3, pp. 19–44 (in
Huang, Y.S. and Hsiao, W.K. (2006), Social Policy and Social Legislation. Yeh Yeh Book Gallery: Taipei (in Chinese).
Huang, Y.Y. (1988), Research on Taiwan's Social Work Development (1683–
1988), thesis, Department of Sociology, National Taiwan University, Taipei.
Hughes, E.C. (1971), The Sociological Eye. Aldine-Atherton: Chicago, IL.
Huo, C.H. (2007), Research on Social Workers' Mindset Southern Taiwan Towards to the Certification System of Social Work, thesis, Institute of Interdisciplinary Studies on Social Sciences, National Sun Yat-Sen University, Kaohsiung, Taiwan (in Chinese).
Johnson, T. (1972), Professions and Power. Macmillan: London.
Kao, T.L. (2003), Professional Certification Examination System of Social Work, Paper presented at the Role of Social Workers and Social Work Education Seminar, Tunghai University: Taichung, Taiwan.
Lai, L.Y. (2002), The Historical Development and Function Transformation of Community Work in Taiwan, Community Development Journal Quarterly, Vol. 100, pp. 69–80.
Larson, M.S. (1977), The Rise of Professionalism: A Sociological Analysis.
University of California Press: Berkeley, CA.
Li, T.L. (1980), The Development Trend of Social Work Supervision, Community Development Journal Quarterly, Vol. 52, pp. 9–11 (in Chinese).
Li, Y.C. (2005), Development of Medical Social Work in Taiwan, Community Development Journal Quarterly, Vol. 109, pp. 165–70 (in Chinese).
Li, Z.P. (1996), Discuss Social Worker Certification and Approval System, Community Development Journal Quarterly, Vol. 76, pp. 24–33 (in Chinese). Lin, W.I. (2002a), The Historical Development of Taiwan's Social Work, in Social Work and Taiwan Society, edited by P.C. Lu (ed.), Chu-Liu Publishing: Taipei
(in Chinese). Lin, W.I. and Shen, S.H. (2008), The Road Towards Specialization: The Next Step of Social Work in Taiwan? Community Development Journal Quarterly, Vol. 121, pp. 199–233 (in Chinese).
Lin, W.L. (1994), The Welfare State—Analysis of Historical Comparison, Taipei: Strong Current (in Chinese).
Lin, W.L. (2001), Looking for the 21st Century Social Work in Taiwan, Social Work Journal, Vol. 7, pp. i–xv (in Chinese)
Lin, W.Y. (2002b), Contemporary Social Work: Theories and Methods Wu Nan: Taipei.
Parry, N. and Parry, J. (1976), The Rise of the Medical Profession: A Study of Collective Social Mobility, Croom Helm: London.
Parsons, T. (1954), The Professions and Social Structure, in Essays in Sociological Theory, edited by T. Parsons (ed.), The Free Press: New York.
Taiwan Association of Social Workers (TASW) (2004), Work Report, Taiwan Association of Social Workers: Taipei (in Chinese).
TASW (2005), Work Report, Taiwan Association of Social Workers: Taipei (in Chinese).
Tao, F.Y. (1999), The Analysis and Prospect of Social Work Development,
Community Development Quarterly, Vol. 88, pp. 190–96 (in Chinese).
Tao, F.Y. and Chien, C.A. (1997), The Review and Prospect of the Development of Social Work Profession, Social Work Journal, Vol. 4, pp. 1–25.
Tsai, H.H. (1989), Establishment of Social Work Profession System: A Cornerstone of Welfare Policy, Social Research Center: Taipei (in Chinese).
Vollmer, H.M. and Mills, D.L. (1966), Professionalization. Prentice-Hall: Englewood Cliffs, NJ.
Wang, C.S. (2003), Research of Social Work Profession Development in Hong Kong: 1950–1997, thesis, Department of Social Welfare, National Chung Cheng University, Taipei.
Wang, Frank T.Y. (2003), Between Care and Control: Discursive Practices of Case Management in Social Work, Taiwan: A Radical Quarterly in Social Studies, Vol. 51, pp. 143–83 (in Chinese).
Wang, S. (2002), Comparing Social Worker and Psychological Counselor Ethics, in Social Work Ethics, edited by J.C. Has and M.C. Li (eds.). Wu Nan: Taipei (in Chinese).
Wang, S. (2006), From Push to Resist: MyAction inthe Process of Institutionalization of Counseling Psychology, Research in Applied Psychology, Vol. 30, pp. 21–36 (in Chinese).
Wang, S.M. (2008), The Humanistic Thinking of Social Workers Law Changed,
report, National Policy Foundation, Taipei, February 4 (in Chinese).
Wilensky, H. (1964), The Professionalization of Everyone?, The American Journal of Sociology, Vol. 70, No. 2, pp. 137–58.
Wilson, G.K. (1984), Social Regulation and Explanations of Regulatory Failure,
Political Studies, Vol. 32, No. 2, pp. 203–25.
Yang, D.C. (1997), Michel Foucault. Sheng-Chih Book: Taipei (in Chinese). Yang, M.Y. (1998), Research on Social Work's Professionalization in Taiwan: Analysis of the Establishment of Professional Social Worker System, thesis, Department of Social Work in Soochow University, Taipei.
Yu, H.Y. (1998), Social Research Ethics, in Dangerous and Secret: Research Ethics, edited by S.R. Yan. Taipei: Sun Min (in Chinese).